Théorie de l'Affaire
Avoid deep water as John — his drowning is instant. Otherwise the differences are flavour that reward replaying the epilogue.
Confidentiel
Is John Better Than Arthur in RDR2?
Comparing John Marston and Arthur Morgan reveals fun gameplay and character differences — most notably that John literally cannot swim.
Emplacement Validé
Comparison across the story and epilogue.
Notes d'enquête
- Swimming: Arthur swims well as long as his stamina lasts; John instantly begins to drown in deep water, staying true to RDR1.
- Drawing and aiming: John keeps his classic hip-fire-heavy animations, while Arthur has a heavier, more deliberate stance.
- Greeting NPCs: Arthur's greetings are friendly and calm; John's are famously awkward and loud, often shouting 'SIR!' or 'HELLO THERE!'
- Journaling: Arthur draws beautiful, detailed sketches; John's journal art is crude, childlike stick figures with sloppy handwriting.
Route d'Investigation
Q: Can John swim? A: No — he drowns almost instantly in deep water, just like in the first game.
Q: Who is the better artist? A: Arthur — John's journal sketches are deliberately terrible.
Investigation Comments
Login to post comments.
No comments yet.